Hi everyone! I’m new here and I’ve read all the Guardian Herd books including the trilogy. But the part where Star defeats Nightwing for good made a question appear in my mind: Did Nightwing ever regret his choices in life? Or did he keep being a Destroyer? Wouldn’t that be against the laws of The G

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ WINBORN SPOILERS IF YOU HAVN"T READ IT DON"T READ ANYMORE OF THIS POST UNLESS YOU WANT TO BE SPOILED~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Here we go: I know some of you think Riversun will grow up to be a villain, while some think she will be good, and others undecided. I personally think s

Rockwing acted like Petalcloud was invisible, she runs away but gives him Frostfire, Rockwing raises Frostfire to be like he is now, and then you have two pegasi who are dangerous. Years before, the over-stallions treat Nightflame like he’s some kind of object meant to do what they say. They treat h

We all know that he was not at all a kind but, I think he has had a hard life. His family has a curse all the colts are born dead ( he had 17 colts all born dead), since all the mares all want to have foals every year mountain herd needs to expand territory, His youngest filly Shadepebble is a dud s

Oakfire is pretty mean. She is the one who rated out Silvercloud/lake for hiding star, she is the one who got her banished from her herd and taken of of her duty as lead mare. I think she did it to become lead mare but, why she was already a captain isn't that enough? She even knew that Thunderwin

The dam of brackentail what happened to her did she join river herd or did she pass in the battle with mountain herd. she never believed that her colt was a betrayer . did she run from her herd out of disappointment to brackentail or was she their the whole time but didn't get a part in the book as

Yeah, so Brauk isn't really a 'villain', but he also isn't exactly everyone's most favorite character. Especially after he mistreated Echofrost, and even ripped out her flight feathers. I honestly think that Brauk more of a brat then the books let on. I get that it must have been hard on Brauk whe

I think Rockwing is the way he is because he had a hard foalhood and was treated poorly as a foal. I think he just needs someone to talk to, and to love him

In every genre of any story whether it be a book or a movie, there will always be favorites. There will always be antagonists and protagonists to every series, but that what i love about it. Good vs bad, light vs dark, heroes vs villains! Also, in every genre, there are the favorite heroes. My favor

So you see in the last book in the TGH series that star defeats Nightwing but , it says the Frostfire, larksong, and Starfrost escaped into the forest. What are they up to now? I think that Frostfire is mad at Star and he takes his family to the woods to plot a plane to take down star and his united

So in Windborn you’ll see that Petalcloud had two foals with Nightwing. The colt was born dead but the filly, who is now known as Riversun, survived. But then both Petalcloud and Nightwing died, and after Star and the rest of the Pegasi go to Crabwing’s Bay to rebuild the tribute, they let the now-m

Okay, so... y'all remember how Star offered to save Nightwing's colt and Riversun's brother? Well, I was thinking, and it's not like Star to just leave the colt dead. I think that maybe (once the last book was over) saved Riversun's brother. Ideas? Questions? I wanna hear 'em.

His grandpa made him be mean he is a good pegasi on the inside but on the outside he seem's mean.

I think Nightwing became evil because of what happened to Hollyblaze. In Nightwing's journey, it's said (well, written) that they were looking at baby crocodiles together (well, Hollyblaze) when the mother comes back. Hollyblaze and Nightflame flee, on hoof because they both know that Nightflame can

Star grew up in a herd that he had friends in, and he felt somewhat safe in Sun Herd. Nightwing may haven't had a life like that, so maybe this caused him to become a destroyer?

Although she is perfect for Star, she is really annoying. Don't you think?

Is it just me or is holly blaze sorta a villain? Now here me out, when I read the short story about her by JLA holly blaze was always getting night wing into trouble, she was also a bit rude to him. Then knowing that nightwing was scared and would not fight, put him in the position to fight and pres

So, @Iceberry and I were discussing whether or not Nightwing went to the Beyond when Star defeated him, and I was curious about all your opinions. So what do you guys think? Did Nightwing go to the Beyond, or the Golden Meadow? Why?

In the first book we all know Brakentail was kinda a bully. But he's really just misunderstood. I mean, he was mean to Star and gave away info because he was trying to protect Morningleaf. And in Landfall (btw if you haven't read Landfall yet don't read this because it's a little bit of a spoiler) w

I mean we all know Frostfire is really a sweetheart inside right? I mean he was abandoned when we was a weanling, raised by a maniac, and trained to be ruthless and cruel. So it really isn't Frostfire's fault why he's like that. It's Rockwing's and Petalcloud's fault.

He didn't try to save Echofrost but, he did it so she wouldn't get punished again. It would be a lie if she came out shinny, sparkly, or as well fed as every other Pegasus. Mountain herd foals are taught to be mean and cold hearted. In the end star always sees the good in everybody and he saw it in

Obviously Frostfire is upset with his mother for what she did to him. But in Windborn it seemed like he had a change of heart and sided with Star, even helping him discover his invisibility powers. But later you find out that he betrays Star by telling Petalcloud about the tunnel and helping her cap

I think Rockwing became evil because of his thurst for power. I mean seriously who snaps foals wings and drops them off a cliff to certain death?

I would think that star would come back if he could to save him but, it said that star lost all of his star fire in the intense battle with Nightwing and he said he had become a normal Pegasus. I also think that the whole united herd would come together and have a real ceremony of the deaths of Nig

i don't mean to be offensive ot what, but Morningleaf is nosy.

At the end of Windborn Frostfire goes with Larksong and Starfrost somewhere else in Anok, and Star mentions that he didn’t think he’ll ever see Frostfire again. But Frostfire HAD to go somewhere. I personally think he went back to Mountain Herd territory, since that was the herd he was part of befor

I think Brackentail deserves to be forgiven for everything he did in Starfire, or he still a bad guy? I think he deserves to be forgiven but I’ll always be Team Starleaf. :D Also I may not respond right away but I’ll check here and there hehe.

So, after a while of staring at the wall thinking (I do that a lot), I realized that Riversun was Starfrost's aunt! And also, Riversun is some how, very weirdly, related to Star! WHA?!?! And honestly, now that I think of it, Petalcloud was nursing her GRANDSON. SUPER WEIRD. UGH, I AM DISTURBED.

WARNING SPOILERS WARNING Related to Star: Rockwing Petalcloud Iceriver Shadepebble Nightwing If I missed any please tell!

I really hate FrostFire. Everyone likes him despite the dude being a complete emo stereotype With barely any justification for what he did. He had almost no development either, and the bit that he did got covered up by his bad boy personality. I don’t believe that he’s misunderstood at all.