I really hate FrostFire. Everyone likes him despite the dude being a complete emo stereotype With barely any justification for what he did. He had almost no development either, and the bit that he did

there is nothing misunderstood about petalcloud she is downright evil evil to the core

Yeah, so Brauk isn't really a 'villain', but he also isn't exactly everyone's most favorite character. Especially after he mistreated Echofrost, and even ripped out her flight feathers. I honestly thi

i don't mean to be offensive ot what, but Morningleaf is nosy.

Now please no one get me wrong on this, I believe that Queen Lilliam was really, truly horrible, but I think that there were probably many things that impacted her bad decisions like NIghtwing. First,

Brackentail bullied Star through out the first year of the black foal's life, he even tried to murder Star. Most of us would have to agree it was pretty despicable of Brackentail to do that, but if yo

Star grew up in a herd that he had friends in, and he felt somewhat safe in Sun Herd. Nightwing may haven't had a life like that, so maybe this caused him to become a destroyer?

SPOILERS FOR THE SHORT STORIES IN STORMBOUND AND WINDBORN So I recently read the short story in the back of Stor

Brakentail seemed evil in the first book but in the second book he humbly asked to be forgiven, and asked to join Stars herd. Since Star is a kind stallion he let brakentail join his herd, and healed

WARNING SPOILERS WARNING Related to Star: Rockwing Petalcloud Iceriver Shadepebble Nightwing If I missed any please tell!

i say one of the reasons he's bad is becuase his mother (Petalcloud) traded him to her Sire (Rockwing) he felt abandoned, and he was afraid of Star, and that he wanted to take over the herds. SPOILER

Though I'm not sure anyone dislikes her yet I thought it would be good to get the message out. River sun is not evil yet. Sure her parents were psychopaths but River sun was only a poor little foal wh

I think Nightwing became evil because of what happened to Hollyblaze. In Nightwing's journey, it's said (well, written) that they were looking at baby crocodiles together (well, Hollyblaze) when the m

I think Rockwing is the way he is because he had a hard foalhood and was treated poorly as a foal. I think he just needs someone to talk to, and to love him

(Minor spoilers for the short story in the back of Stormbound) (You might also be wondering why I posted this in ‘Misunderstood Villains’. Nightwing’s mother isn’t exactly a villain (or at least she

Frostfire is not all bad in fact he is one of my favortie villins in TGH . Riversun i feel bad for her having mean parents and being a orphan must be hard for Rivesun . Brakentail is one of the bes

Frostfiire isn''t that bad! Seriously, I think he got most of his traits from Petalcloud. (SPOILERS) He only betrayed Star to save his colt! And he captured Morningleaf because Rockwing told him to.

He did seem really evil and cruel, but he was given away to Mountain Herd by his own mother which probably made him bitter. The flashback he had from his point of view was really sad. I also ship him