Star because I would want to see what other things he could do with his Starfire and because he is so Kind, Caring, and Loving (Especially for Lightfeather, Morningleaf and Silverlake)
Discussion
I think Bumblewind would be my answer if he were still alive because he was so caring and empathetic.
Seeing Star before he used up his starfire would have been cool (and a little scary considering I would have no clue how he would react to us landwalkers)
That's true, but since he has such a kind heart he would probably try to protect his herd until he found out we were harmless, and then I could ride in his shield with him!
YOU FORGOT BUMBLEWIND AHHHHH.