Your Right Shes downright evil i was so happy when she got crushed my the stone tribute i cant even believe well i can knowing her that she hurt Frostfires Mate
Precsiely. So, what would have happened if Petalcloud was raised by a loving father? But also, if she you think about it, if Petalcloud never left to be Icewing’s mate, Frostfire wouldn’t have been born. If Petalcloud didn’t give Frostfire to Rockwing, he wouldn’t have met Larksong, and Starfrost would be nonexistent.
XD Nightwinf wasn’t always bad either, though. Mrs. Alvarez kept foreshawing that he wasn’t always so dark. Something happened to change him, something involving Hollyblaze perhaps. Makes you wonder... If something had happened to Morningleaf, would Star have turned as well?
I still think Petalcloud is evil, and I just remembered thanks to Cass what she said to Star when he first sprung his shield. AND STEALING STARFROST??!!! Yeah, it was about time when she got crushed.
3. As stated a few times throughout the series, Mountain Herd mares are plain, shaggy, and unattractive. Except for Petalcloud. She was the most beautiful of them all, perhaps the most beautiful mare in all of Anok. The praise might have gone to her head.
4. Petalcloud was trapped in a crippled herd where she was ignored and isolated. She wanted to escape the poor conditions her life had to offer, and seized the opportunity when it arose. Icewing wanted a lead mare. She was beautiful, had noble lineage, and was very, very desperate. She got what she wanted. When Rockwing demanded a colt for her precious freedom, Petalcloud readily made the trade.
No one is born evil. But all are born with the capability to be evil.
There are plenty of ways that could have influenced Petalcloud’s turn:
*SPOILERS*
1. Petalcloud was born into Mountain Herd, a herd suffering from poverty caused by overpopulation. With starvation and rough climate on the inside and territory hungry pegasi on the outside, the Mountain Herd steeds were virtually trapped. Petalcloud was born here, where only the strongest survive.
2. I think we can all agree that Rockwing isn’t the model father. Frostfire is obvious proof of what happens to a young foal maturing under his influence. As Framefrost pointed out, Petalcloud was ignored by her father, likely because she was a fully and not a colt like he wanted. She was simply a vessel to produce more warriors.
I do think she is evil, but the short story in Stormbound, we hear that she left Rockwing because he didn't notice her and she wanted recognition as well as power. I think that she was bitter of her sire's treatment.I still think she's terrible, but cut some slack plz
Now I think about it Riversun probably didn't hate Petalcloud, and I don't think Stormtail did either, or Nightwing, or Icewing/Iceriver, most of the Ice warriors.....okay maybe not everyone hates Petalcloud
Oh my goodness same!!!!! I wish I could just jump into the book and tackle her, then have the United Army finish her.. but not until I tell her that speaking to Star that way was a mistake.. (sorry.. I really hate her O_o)
Yep that just about covers Petalcloud!!! My least fav thing she did EVER was when star was in his sheild in landfall and she pressed her (stupid) face against the glass and said stuff like 'You woke Nightwing up." " there is no one to blame"
That made me sooooo mad if i was in the book while this was hapenning i would hav tackled her
Ahh.. sry i rant sometimes about how unfair she is
She gave up her SON (her ONE LIVING son) for freedom who does that????!!!
Yes! I know that there are those who are born without empathy! And are unable to care about anyone other then themselves!!! They have no sense of love and are usually ALWAYS ANGRY!!!!! It's almost like they can't see that other people have feelings!! And that the world DOESN'T REVOLVE AROUND THEM!!!!! Petalcloud is just like these people! That's why she was able to give away her son without feeling a thing!!!
i was almost glad when SPOILER ALERT she got crushed by the tribute sry but that is my opinion like in my head i was saying finally star can be rid of her
I don’t hate petalcloud erm.. fifth favorite character... DONT KILL ME PWEEZS
You have the ability to choose your own choices.
well, i might be like taht is i had rockwing as a sire.
yep
Your Right Shes downright evil i was so happy when she got crushed my the stone tribute i cant even believe well i can knowing her that she hurt Frostfires Mate
Well Petalcloud sire was heartless she probably learned from him and she did love her son Frostfire but loved herself
I missed a totally awesome "critisize Petalcloud" post!
Yeah, but I think she was so cold hearted she never would.
I am always annoyed of Petalcloud, but I feel sad that Nightwing killed her and she didn't get a chance to ever ask for forgiveness
Agreed Isabella
Yes, kinda XD
True. So I guess it all worked out in the end... kinda
Precsiely. So, what would have happened if Petalcloud was raised by a loving father? But also, if she you think about it, if Petalcloud never left to be Icewing’s mate, Frostfire wouldn’t have been born. If Petalcloud didn’t give Frostfire to Rockwing, he wouldn’t have met Larksong, and Starfrost would be nonexistent.
oh got it
Oops his life
not care about his what?
I think Star would’ve been to lost in grief and not care about his life if Morningleaf really did die
Good question, what if Morningleaf had died? *spoiler!!!* not killing herself by taking the deathblow
*Nightwing, oops spell error XP
XD Nightwinf wasn’t always bad either, though. Mrs. Alvarez kept foreshawing that he wasn’t always so dark. Something happened to change him, something involving Hollyblaze perhaps. Makes you wonder... If something had happened to Morningleaf, would Star have turned as well?
I still think Petalcloud is evil, and I just remembered thanks to Cass what she said to Star when he first sprung his shield. AND STEALING STARFROST??!!! Yeah, it was about time when she got crushed.
XD Alrighty then
That is true, but Petalcloud not being born evil? I cant agree with that..
3. As stated a few times throughout the series, Mountain Herd mares are plain, shaggy, and unattractive. Except for Petalcloud. She was the most beautiful of them all, perhaps the most beautiful mare in all of Anok. The praise might have gone to her head.
4. Petalcloud was trapped in a crippled herd where she was ignored and isolated. She wanted to escape the poor conditions her life had to offer, and seized the opportunity when it arose. Icewing wanted a lead mare. She was beautiful, had noble lineage, and was very, very desperate. She got what she wanted. When Rockwing demanded a colt for her precious freedom, Petalcloud readily made the trade.
No one is born evil. But all are born with the capability to be evil.
There are plenty of ways that could have influenced Petalcloud’s turn:
*SPOILERS*
1. Petalcloud was born into Mountain Herd, a herd suffering from poverty caused by overpopulation. With starvation and rough climate on the inside and territory hungry pegasi on the outside, the Mountain Herd steeds were virtually trapped. Petalcloud was born here, where only the strongest survive.
2. I think we can all agree that Rockwing isn’t the model father. Frostfire is obvious proof of what happens to a young foal maturing under his influence. As Framefrost pointed out, Petalcloud was ignored by her father, likely because she was a fully and not a colt like he wanted. She was simply a vessel to produce more warriors.
I do think she is evil, but the short story in Stormbound, we hear that she left Rockwing because he didn't notice her and she wanted recognition as well as power. I think that she was bitter of her sire's treatment.I still think she's terrible, but cut some slack plz
I do to :)
I hate Petalcloud!!! 😠😡
I know, that's what it just seemed like to me
Yeah... who knows what he thought
Yeah but Icewing didn't hate her, I think he wanted to believe Petalcloud would chose good over evil in the end
U can say that again! lol
Im glad she's gone!
I think Icewing didn't mind Petalcloud until she gave up Frostfire, but after that I don't think he liked her anymore
sry meant aren't
Well..... yeah but arrant the people here glad shes gone i mean..... I AM!! sry petalcloud but u went down that path
Now I think about it Riversun probably didn't hate Petalcloud, and I don't think Stormtail did either, or Nightwing, or Icewing/Iceriver, most of the Ice warriors.....okay maybe not everyone hates Petalcloud
Hopefully.....
I think everyone hates Petalcloud
Oh my goodness same!!!!! I wish I could just jump into the book and tackle her, then have the United Army finish her.. but not until I tell her that speaking to Star that way was a mistake.. (sorry.. I really hate her O_o)
Yep that just about covers Petalcloud!!! My least fav thing she did EVER was when star was in his sheild in landfall and she pressed her (stupid) face against the glass and said stuff like 'You woke Nightwing up." " there is no one to blame"
That made me sooooo mad if i was in the book while this was hapenning i would hav tackled her
Ahh.. sry i rant sometimes about how unfair she is
She gave up her SON (her ONE LIVING son) for freedom who does that????!!!
That's completely right Autumnsky
Yes! I know that there are those who are born without empathy! And are unable to care about anyone other then themselves!!! They have no sense of love and are usually ALWAYS ANGRY!!!!! It's almost like they can't see that other people have feelings!! And that the world DOESN'T REVOLVE AROUND THEM!!!!! Petalcloud is just like these people! That's why she was able to give away her son without feeling a thing!!!
Yeah
Yeah no kidding
yeah CassTucker1 i am just like... a grusome death but it was for the better now anok is 10 times safer
To be honest, same. The first thing I thought was: 'Bout time she died!' Yeah it's a bit harsh.. but I was kinda happy...
i was almost glad when SPOILER ALERT she got crushed by the tribute sry but that is my opinion like in my head i was saying finally star can be rid of her
-nods like crazy- No kidding!
Yes she is