Well said Sophia, well said.

Starfire:

Brackentail shouldn't have been jeolous or killed him. When Brackentail was captured, Morningleaf was beaten, it wasnt his fault but he shouldn't have listened to Rockwing, he should have fought with his life to protect her, just like star would. And Rockwing only said if you threaten to bargain he will kill her. Not fighting back. I think of him at that point a coward. And in the rest of the books he would fight his life for MORNINGLEAF.

Stormbound: We can't blame Star for forgiving Brackentail. Imagine seeing a beaten body, broken wing, and sad, dead, pleading eyes. Plus the fact that it reminded him of himself. It was right to do this. But I wish he hadn't. He hadnt shown thanks. He didnt care. There was proove when he said '"I wouldn't do that morningleaf." he looked directly at morningleaf' He should be focusing on repaying Star. Not trying to win Morningleaf over. In this series Brackentail hadnt done TO much disturbance.

Landfall: When Brackentail went with Morningleaf even when she DIDNT give permission he saved her life multiple times. Why couldn't he save Echofrost's? When they set off he had shown multiple signs of jeolousy deep within him such as the quotes, "I know, you just want star." and "I am lost." When Brackentail went on there adventure my only favorite part was a hint that Morningleaf loved star and not Morningleaf, "You are the bravest pegasi I know, next to Star."

When they came back from the journey, yes star was jelly, but I couldn't blame him. Imagine how would you feel. Forgiving your enemy that tried to kill you just to find out that he just wanted to win back Morningleaf. Though, he handled his slight jeolousy better than Brackentail did, Brackentail tried to to kill him very much unlike Star.

Windborn: By far this show how the two grown ever so close. Star's jeolusy grew but he still adored the stallion in contrast to Brackentail back then. I have less to speak about this. Though it conforted me at the quote. "Though Morningleaf have been more alive with him. And Star didnt think he was wrong."

My main reason why I like Starleaf is because...

1. They are born on the same day.

2. Star is bigger and handsomer than Brackentail.

3. The foal of Starleaf would result in a black foal, which could be a swell continuation of TGH

4. They have been closer for a longer time.

5. Brackentail, as I said, still has signs of jeolousy.

6. Brackentail saved MORNINGLEAF'S LIFE COUNTLESS TIME RISKING HIS OWN LIFE AND HE DIDNT DO THE SAME TO POOR ECHOFROST!

7. Starleaf really sounds better than Brackenleaf XD

These all the reasons why I hate Brackenleaf and love Starleaf.

Very.

Thats very true

Brackentail isnt bad and i still like him, anyway star and morningleaf are soposed to be together anyone who doesnt ship them is cray-cray

and plus Brackentail and morningleaf are just good friends, like Echofrost and star

Cool!

Thanks i just got back from vacation so i got to catch up with all the short stories

Madison, you should write more posts! I would definitely agree with anything you said!

WOW. That would be an amazing opportunity!!!

Yeah... once I think I dreamed about being in the books and having a talk to Morningleaf about staying away from Brackentail....

Same!!!!!!!!!!😩 I get so mad!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ya, but in Windborn they were soooooo close and I really wanted to change that......

CassTucker and Madison u r both so true!!! Brackentail just needs to back off cause him and Morningleaf will NEVER happen. It even SAYS in Landfall that when Shadepebble and Morngleaf planned to be a decoy to get the Ice Warriors and Black Army away from him, when Brackentail overhears them, it says "Morningleaf was about to say 'no' when Silverlake interrupted them (blah blah) *But Morngleaf still didnt want Brackentail to come along. SHE HAD ONLY ACCEPTED HIM BECAUSE STAR HAD, AND SHE STILL DIDNT TRUST HIM*

I AGREE!!!!! Everything you say is so true, Brackentail just needs to back off

I like brackentail when hes not around morningleaf. hes a great character when hes not trying to steal morningleaf or kill star

Tried not trued